I have a bone to pick with society. This is something I feel very passionate about, and that’s the subject of monogamy. Or, rather, nonmonogamy. Polyamory, or whichever word you want to use. Maybe my thoughts and ideas are so far out there that not many people can relate, and that is frustrating. To be honest, many of my ideas are outside of societal norms, which has gotten me defriended and labeled as some sort of deviant, which I guess I am. But now when I say anything about my thoughts that many don’t agree with, no one will talk with me about it. So I don’t say much of anything to anymore, even to people I know are on the same wavelength as myself.
I’m going to say this anyway, because I think it’s important. It’s important to me to get a sex positive message out there, as well as relationship positive. My goal is to help people be more healthy in their relationships, and I think the notion of monogamy is a very large part of that. I hope my thoughts aren’t too jumbled, I will try and organize them here.
First, let’s look at a little history. It’s well-known that the Church was involved in marriages long before any government was, and it was the Church that first benefited from marriage. And as we know, marriage is supposed to be with one person, for the rest of your life, and marriage was generally one considered for reasons other than love. Usually family lines for more prominent families, and ones of survival for the poorer families. The United States has been founded on the Puritan beliefs that first came over here from Europe. As the world has changed, partnerships have become ones more based on love and emotional connections rather than ones of convenience or necessity. There’s been this strange melding of old-world beliefs and new ideas. One that I find particularly damaging is the notion of finding “the one.” There’s still the idea that we should only be with one person (or, at least, married to one person) ever, but now we can marry for love! That must be fantastic!
However, as we have moved from marriages of necessity to ones of love, we have seen many things happen. We’ve seen the number of divorces skyrocket, the number of depressed and anxious people greatly increased, and hopelessness regarding relationships. There are different reasons for these things, but we can also think about how we feel when a relationship ends or a marriage. One of the top thoughts and feelings is one of failure. What did I do wrong? I should have tried harder. And then, since the notion of The One is perpetrated in popular culture through Disney movies, romantic comedies, music, television, and more, we continually feel worthless if we haven’t found that. And chances are, most of us haven’t. Cheating is also a problem. Since the Church has the idea out there that having feelings for someone else and engaging in romantic activities with someone else is sinful and immoral, it creates these huge feelings of guilt and shame even if we have these feelings and don’t act upon them. And if the other partner finds out, they are hurt and afraid and jealous.
Why are there all these problems? If we are now allowed to freely make decisions about our partners based on love, why do these things happen? I think what people don’t realize or understand or perhaps haven’t thought of, is that love is fluid, it is not finite, it does not adhere to these rules, and it doesn’t have to stay. It is not a constant. It takes different forms, and it feels differently with different people. People say that it’s hard to define love, and this is why. But if they realize that, why do they insist on this defining of marriage with one person forever, or having to have “the one”? Why are we shocked when our partner falls for someone else?
Let us consider a different history, before organized religion, and perhaps even before the agricultural revolution (so about 10,000 years ago). It’s been said that evidence of nonmonogamy has been buried and destroyed and ignored by archaeologists because the evidence doesn’t fit into our neat boxes of how we view the world today and our ideas. I don’t have any references on this at the moment, but I will make a post of that once I do (I have the book Sex At Dawn that I have yet to read). But in this history of the world, people loved more freely in their groups, and everyone helped raise the children. Monogamy wasn’t a thing. Maybe in some groups it was, I’m sure, but I don’t think that it was as widespread as we are led to believe.
Consensual nonmonogamy would solve so many of the problems I mentioned earlier, and I think it’s a much more natural course of action. If it wasn’t, we wouldn’t be attracted to other people when we are already in a relationship. First, it solves the problem of even looking for the perfect person and continuously being disappointed and frustrated and depressed when it doesn’t happen. If we understand that love doesn’t fit this definition, why even bother with this? It would save so much heartache.
Then there’s the matter of divorce. Personally, I don’t even believe in the concept of marriage because of its history and origins (women are property and sold by their fathers and then “given away” at the alter, as well as the religious aspect). My personal feelings aside, if people had nonmonogamous marriages, I’m certain that divorce rates would drop. One of the top reasons for divorce is cheating, which ties into that negative of monogamy. If we had the consent of our partners to pursue other relationships, the feelings of guilt and shame would essentially drop off. Maybe there would be some of those feelings, or some apprehension, but there would be far less of it in my opinion. As for the other partner, maybe there would be some lingering feelings of hurt and fear, but I think those feelings are mainly from the thought that we could lose our partner to someone else. That is certainly a valid fear to have, to be honest, especially if we take into consideration that love is not stagnant and not a constant. But with that, should come the understanding that you too can fall for another person. As far as jealousy, that is also a very valid feeling. But it shouldn’t necessarily be considered a bad thing or negative. To deal with this, we have to have open and honest communication with our partners, as well as trust. Talk about the jealousy, and comfort each other when it happens, and trust each other with their words and actions.
Thankfully, my generation and the newer generations are continuing to pursue these freer ideas of sex, sexuality, and relationships that can be a lot more healthy if they are handled properly. Will polyamory ever be considered the “norm”? Probably not, and if it ever is, it’s far, far into the future. I think there’s a lot of work to do to undo the unhealthy ideas that have been circulating for quite some time, but I’m starting to see some improvements through discussions on these “newer” ideas, or regenerating ideas from the past that are starting to come forth once again. And I like seeing that.